Solutions for the Offside Rule? Anyone?

How many times have you experienced that awful feeling when your team loses thanks to a bad call from the referee? I know I have. As a player and as a fan, it's always a dissapointment when an unfair goal is counted or when a legitimate goal is denied. It is certainly always a controversy.

It does not matter at what level, the dissapointment is the same. Take the offside rule for example, probably the most controversial rule in the soccer world. It's so important that the argument has been made that the offside rule should just simply be eliminated.

In December, 2004 ScienceDaily revealed a study. It stated that "To apply the offside rule correctly, the referee must be able to keep at least five moving objects in his visual field at the same time (two players of the attacking team, the last two players of the defending team, and the ball)." This is impossible to do by the human eye. This means that most offside calls are by chance and not because a referees see them clearly. If allowed to stand, the offside rule will keep bringing controversy to the sport. As a plus, critics of the rule also argue that offsides take emotion away from the game by making it even more difficult to score.

FIFA, the all-knowing organization, has actually made matters worse. By implementing "clarifications to the rule" such as stating that players "actively involved in play" are offside, FIFA has made the job much harder for referees around the world by making them reach a decision in a split second . It goes without saying that this "clarifications" have made referees the biggest targets to insults and abuse. (I'm not proud to admit it, but I help this cause almost everytime I watch a game. I try to sympathize with refs, but man it's hard!)

So, what's the solution? Do we eliminate the offside rule? Do we bring techology in the picture? Add extra refs? or just stop whinning and leave it alone?

Will Soccer Reach The American Dream?

If you are a soccer maniac (like me) and live in the United States (like me), you might be suffering from the same pain I suffer from and completely understand my question. For those of you who don't understand, I'll ask you a simpler question: Why in the hell is soccer the most famous sport every else in the world, except the United States?

According to John Neves, a former PR representative for the New York Red Bulls, football, baseball, and even hockey have been around for longer and the people with the money in this country grew up in those sports. “There is just simply no room for soccer” he said.

The media in the United States needs to focus on the sports that people watch. They need to keep their ratings up. The fact that soccer is not a sport in demand makes the media overlook it. This way, soccer has a difficult time getting promoted.

“The majority of people want to read more about the Yankees than about the Red Bulls” Neves said. “Soccer’s recognition is growing because the longer that soccer sticks around, the more fans they’ll get.”

And that seems to be true. I spoke with Petar Rakovik, captain of the NCAA Division I Stony Brook Seawolves, about a year ago. He is a guy that has seen the way soccer is lived here and in his native Serbia. He is optimistic about the growing popularity of soccer and he argued that because of the effects of globalization and the advances of technology, people in the States are more connected with soccer. That may be true as well. I mean, back in the day people did not have access to Serie A games or the Premier league. Nowadays we can catch those games from our couch thanks to Fox Soccer Channel, ESPN, and GoalTV. From that point of view, the future of soccer in the U.S looks promising.

Still, there are those who are more skeptical.

My coach (ex-coach?) Dima Kamenshchik from Baruch College, an outstanding Division III team said, "[soccer] will probably never reach the popularity that football and baseball enjoy." He might be right also.

I really do wonder. I wonder if I will ever see soccer become a very popular sport here in New York. If it does, it might take some time. An MLS game brings in crowds of 17,000 people (sometimes), while an English Premier League game can easily double that amount. It's a long way to go...

In any case, do you believe that soccer will be very popular in U.S someday? Do you believe it will happen in our lifetime? Will soccer reach the American Dream? I sure hope so. What do you think?